Faux-Feminist Friends

Anyone else get frustrated when your feminist-identified male friends have extremely anti-feminist moments? IE:

a)    they make a rape joke (“it’s funny when it’s bro-rape!!”)

b)   they reduce other women to anatomy (“OMG boobies and tits”)

c)    they assert “expert” opinions on issues like street harassment, abortion, and sexism in the workplace (“women should wear modest clothing so they won’t be harassed!”)

d)   they make a “woman joke” around you just to piss you off (“you’re so cute when you are angry!”)

e)    they pretend to be manly around you just to piss you off (“oh, I’m a MAN, ha ha ha, what are you going to do, WOMAN?? Ha ha ha”)

Etc etc.  Don’t get me wrong—I love when guys say that they are feminists and mean it.  I’ve had great discussions with men who support my ideas and/or expand my ideas with their own unique takes on gender issues.  But some guys don’t get that feminism isn’t just a “sometimes” belief—it’s a way of life. 

(note: do women do this too? I have never had a female friend like that, but maybe they are out there.)

Posted by Roodies24 - August 22, 2008, at 09:41AM | in Anti-Feminism
2

0 TrackBacks

Listed below are links to blogs that reference this entry: Faux-Feminist Friends.

TrackBack URL for this entry: http://www.feministing.com/cgi-bin/movabletype/mt-tb.fcgi/8827

11 Comments

[0+] Author Profile Page Alexandra said:

I've had a couple female friends that probably think they're feminists but have said things like:

1) Girls (meaning young women) ARE bitchy and petty. Guys are more interesting and make better friends.

2) All my closest friendships are with men. My girlfriends are just people I bullshit with.

3) I wouldn't date a guy who likes art, even though I love art. It makes them seem wimpy.

4) Most of the graduating class from the nursing school is women. It's are to argue that there's not something genetic at work there.

Unfortunately, these were honest sentiments - not meant to provoke or piss anyone off. So, I guess my point is that faux or superficial feminism is not limited to men.

[0+] Author Profile Page Femi2008 said:

YES! I have a male friend that specifically makes comments just to watch me go off, he likes getting the rise out of me. One of my pet peeves is when people use the "you're such a girl" or "you throw like a girl", etc. Any insult that relies on the idea that being a girl or doing something in a "girly" way is something to be ashamed of... Since this is a pet peeve of mine, this certain male friend loves to toss it around in my presence as much as possible.

[0+] Author Profile Page Alexandra said:

Oops - my bullet point #4 up there was supposed to say:

4) Most of the graduating class from the nursing school is women. It's HARD to argue that there's not something genetic at work there.

Sorry for the typo.

[0+] Author Profile Page Luna said:

2) All my closest friendships are with men. My girlfriends are just people I bullshit with.

How does this make anyone less of a feminist?

[0+] Author Profile Page sarah said:

Luna:

It's not that it makes someone less of a feminist, it just feels sexist when you hear someone say that. Most girls I know have said something along the lines of "I'd rather hang out with guys because girls are _ _ _ _" (insert drama,annoying,loud,too girly, or some other offensive/sexist adjective on the dotted line.)

I would add to that list making jokes about beating up your significant other and making comments about celebrities that are too fat/too thin.

And with a lot of these things, I've heard women too.

[0+] Author Profile Page AgnesScottie said:

A female friend was the one who sent me to a link on bro rape. My girlfriends and I chat about our own boobs and our friends boobs regularly (usually in complaining about inability to find clothes or bras that fit them correctly, for large or small)

Almost all of my boyfriends male friends and sometimes my bf are guilty of D) and E) and if you get pissed off about it they feel like they've "won" and you're a humorless feminist. It bothers me to no freaking end.

[0+] Author Profile Page Dominique said:

[quote]if you get pissed off about it they feel like they've "won" and you're a humorless feminist. It bothers me to no freaking end.[/quote]

Yes - exactly!!! I have what is called the "wit of the staircase" (thinking of good replies and repartees while climbing the stairs to get home). But this is giving me the idea of generating my own list of zingers and one-liners to reply to so-called "humour" that is downright offensive. Since the latter follows a standard pattern anyway, it's probably doable...

[0+] Author Profile Page Sharpe said:

I hear you! No one has ever made a rape "joke" around me, but I deal with Mr. Expert on Women's Issues and Mr. I am all MAN you are all WOMAN ha ha as well as Ms. All women are ----. My favourite of these moments was when an actor friend told me, "Puck and Ariel should be played by men because these roles are POWERFUL." Since these are my friends, not random dudes on the street, I take the time to say things like, "you know that joke really trivializes something incredibly traumatizing, right?" or "you do know that women are powerful too, right?"
There's also the guys who think they're "just being ironic" when they say things like, "women belong in the kitchen" with a straight face. Our work is never done...

Roodies24, I know exactly what you mean. I think there are a lot of guys who would call themselves feminists because they DO respect women (in general, even if they insult or make fun of specific women or groups of women-- anyone else ever get the "You're cool because you're smart. A lot of girls are just bimbos"?). But I think there's a big difference between respecting and admiring women, and actually acknowledging their own privilege and working to end it. Hence the "Woman, go make me a sandwich!" joke-but-not-really-a-joke that they all seem to think is so fucking funny.

[0+] Author Profile Page blondegirl said:

I question first why you would call a guy who would say such things a "friend". Someone making inflammatory comments just to piss me off would have their butt handed to them on a platter. Plain and simple, I wouldn't put up with it. I have been called "ball buster" and worse for calling guys out on things like this- and do I care if they no longer consider me a friend?

Hahahaha.... I think you can guess the answer to that.

Leave a comment


Search Feministing
About Feministing Community
Feministing Community is a forum for a variety of feminist voices and organizations.
Related Posts
Related Feministing Posts
Recent Community Comments
Feministing As You Like It
Get involved with Feministing by joining our networks on:
Subscribe to Feministing
Weekly Feministing Newsletter