More on the McCain-Ingraham dustup. Dahlia Lithwick's article at Slate was so fascinating, I didn't want it to get lost in "Comment Land."
You. Have. Got. To. Be. Kidding. This is the female version of the Rush Limbaugh-Michael Steele -David Frum smackdown for the soul of the GOP? One skinny blonde attacking another skinny blonde who is angrily defended by a third skinny blonde, after which everyone retires in a huff to their favorite health blogs to angrily discuss the importance of a positive body image and the need to support a healthy body mass index?
Ever wonder why some men think women are less than serious political thinkers? It certainly helps explain why so many men continue to believe that when it comes to "political discourse," women are all long, sprawling legs and silky blond hair in a tangle on the dessert cart. It's one thing to air your dirty laundry. But are we really stupid enough to be having a front-page battle over a plus-size thong?
As much as I appreciated Meghan McCain's direct response, I think Lithwick has a point. What could have been an enlightening, and much needed, discussion about Republican policies devolved into a "women's" discussion about body image. Ingraham was totally out of line in her response, but I wish McCain had refused the bait. Give one good size-related response (I think "kiss my fat ass" worked) and then get back on target with your original message. What say you, feminists?


0 TrackBacks
Listed below are links to blogs that reference this entry: What Message Did the McCain-Ingraham Fight Send About Conservative Women?.
TrackBack URL for this entry: http://www.feministing.com/cgi-bin/movabletype/mt-tb.fcgi/12603













I can really understand both sides of this debate, including what you're saying, and Meghan Mccain's defence. I think a lot of young girls needed to hear what she had to say (and a lot of tabloids as well). As for her political savy, she will keep right on going with that, I'm sure.
I do understand your point though. It's kind of like giving into an unwanted argument by arguing back instead of walking away. But maybe celebrities, and famous, important female figures in this country could do that if their weight, dress, and relationship issues weren't constantly plastered and berated all over the media.
I actually really liked how Ms. McCain handled it. It doesn't get said enough, and it needs to be.
I feel Meghan McCain couldn't have just let this kind of comment slip. Body image is a true issue affecting so many young girls. I think she did a good job of publicly addressing it.
I completely agree that this could have been an opportune moment for female conservatives to discuss fundamental ideals of the Republican party. I think it's sad and unfortunate that instead all women involved appear immature and unable to discuss real issues.
If women want to earn respect in a male dominated arena, we need to stop knocking each other down based on meaningless characteristics such as weight.
Ever wonder why some men think women are less than serious political thinkers? It certainly helps explain why so many men continue to believe that when it comes to "political discourse," women are all long, sprawling legs and silky blond hair in a tangle on the dessert cart.
I couldn't disagree more. If some people are so ignorant as to conclude that a few conventionally attractive women paraded around mainstream outlets are representative of the whole spectrum of politically minded women that the world has to offer, then that is their bias and problem.
"Ever wonder why some men think women are less than serious political thinkers?"
Don't Rush Limbaugh, Sean Hannity, et.al lead some women to believe that men are less than serious political thinkers?