http://web.blogads.com/advertise/liberal_blog_advertising_network
Liberal Prose BlogAds Network
an un-feminist halloween

Hi all. I'd like to first start by saying that I consider myself to be a feminist and have many strong feminist opinions. I don't agree with objectifying women and am disappointed on a daily basis when I see it happening everywhere in society, the media, etc.

With all these opinions that I have, I find myself facing a personal dilemma. I love dressing "sexy" for Halloween.

For the past several years I have worn pretty revealing costumes, and have basically been contributing to what I have come to believe is a detriment to our world. I like the way the costumes look on me and I enjoy the compliments that I get. Part of me feels guilty about walking around like a sex object and I feel like a hypocrite. Does anyone else ever experience these feelings?

I guess I'll file this one under anti-feminism, since I'm feeling a bit guilty for betraying my feminist beliefs.

Posted by Karnie Claire - October 07, 2009, at 10:05PM | in Anti-Feminism
2

0 TrackBacks

Listed below are links to blogs that reference this entry: an un-feminist halloween.

TrackBack URL for this entry: http://www.feministing.com/cgi-bin/movabletype/mt-tb.fcgi/16455

16 Comments

[0+] Author Profile Page starryeyed.kid21 said:

Own it.

It's your body, you're comfortable, and you love to do it.

Granted, perhaps you should make your own, instead of purchasing one? Then you wouldn't be contributing to the market of it.

[0+] Author Profile Page ElleStar said:

While a lot of the uber-sexy Halloween costumes baffle me, I don't really see anything wrong with them in that they are costumes.

On Halloween, people can dress up in ways they normally don't. It's like playing a part, IMO.

Dressing as a sexy schoolgirl one Halloween when I was much, much younger, I found that it actually reinforced my feminism. I was curious as to what dressing so sexy would achieve. It turned out, it achieved a lot of harassment and catcalling. It was enough that I don't do the overtly sexy costumes any more.

You could always be a female chauvinist pig for Halloween. :P lol.

All joking aside, I find that women's choices for costumes (not just what is made for women but costumes based on female characters in comics and tv and such) are generally overly sexy. Many strong female characters like Wonder Woman or She Hulk or Catwoman wear costume that many would describe as "sexy." I'm going as Tank Girl this Halloween, a character I ADORE because she's just so freakin' awesome, but if you look up pictures of her it's mostly tattered short shorts/skirts and lacy bras. Was gonna do the tattered t-shirt with the red and blue circles on it since it's fairly iconic and a bit more covering, although I don't really expect anyone to be all "Tank Girl! Rock on!" since I don't think anyone even remembers the comic even if they read it. :) So yeah, it's kind of just the luck of being a woman. If you want to go as a character you're gonna end up with boobs everywhere and some thigh showing. Unless you go as something generic like a zombie or a witch or something that is typical Halloween but not a specific character one would be hard pressed to be a modest Trick Or Treater.

And I say more power to you in your costume decisions. If I felt more confident in some of those outfits I'd be right out there with ya, lol. And not like you dress like that everyday (or at least I assume you don't from your post). It's Halloween, have fun with your bad self. :D

[0+] Author Profile Page Marj replied to pmsrhino :

Now I want to find a Samus costume...but then I'd have to roll up into a little ball like an armadillo.

As long as it's the cool armor outfit and not the skin tight blue zero suit. How I curse that skin tight zero suit. *shakes fist at Smash bro brawl, since I blame Brawl for using it for unnecessary close up butt shots during cinematics*

[0+] Author Profile Page Okra replied to pmsrhino :

"So yeah, it's kind of just the luck of being a woman."

This sentence struck me as inexpressably poignant.

So much bad "luck" out there, no? So many accidents of birth resulting in female sexual organs, ethnic minorities, gay people, and other unluckies.

Funny how "luck" just happens...it's no one's fault...it's just the way things are, and have been...some people are just born "unluckier" than others...and we have to shrug and pull out the old lacy bra and take our unlucky lumps.

Maybe we should be working (harder) on trying to change our existential bad "luck."

The line between dressing for oneself and dressing in a manner that contributes to objectification can be somewhat blury. The determining of where that line is is a matter of personal opinion and comfort.

I favour the thinking that a woman has a right to dress in whatever manner she chooses. If you choose to dress sexily for a Halloween costume, cool. If not, cool. The point is that it's your choice. And an important part of this choice is that you've thought about and reflected upon it, and have made a choice that's right for you.

Will there be people that objectify you if you wear the sexy outfit? Yes. Is that reason in itself to not wear the sexy outfit? No. We can not control how others will respond. Some will compliment you on your outfit, to which you can say thank you, and some may comment in a way that objectifies you, to which you can reply I don't appreciate that type of comment. You don't have to launch into a femminist critique of the objectification of women every time a person makes an objectifying comment or gesture: "I don't appreciate that", or "that's innappropriate" can be enough.

So, basically, enjoy youself, and wear what you want.

[0+] Author Profile Page Athenia said:

Halloween is a time when the rules are lax and people will be what they're not (maybe!).

I think it's more of a commentary about where are society is at rather than a personal betrayal of feminism. For example, apparently a sexy nurse is more "transgressive" than a zombie.

I think if you're dressing that way as an opportunity to express yourself in a way you normally wouldn't, that's cool and empowering.

And just as long as you don't dress up as Juno.

[0+] Author Profile Page Honeybee said:

As others have said - go for it. It's your body you can do as you like. Based on your post you've clearly thought about it and seem to be doing it for valid reasons, which is a good thing.

I personally get majorly turned on by having guys look at me in sexy outfits like that... it really does it for me. So I also have generally been one to wear some pretty sexy costumes at halloween, etc. I usually feel better doing it at halloween, like somehow it's less of a feminist betrayal because it's only once a year and most do, but deep down I know it shouldn't make any diff what day of the year it is. So I'm actually still working on resolving the internal conflicts I have about dressing sexy throughout the year, which I tend to do but often feel bad about. This is a perfect example of where I feel you just cannot win. Do what makes you happy but arguably support something you dislike, or make yourself unhappy where probably no one will notice anyways. What to do? I usually go with what makes me happy as long as my conscience isn't too hurt by it.

It's your body. Don't let anyone -- even if they're feminist and swear they have your best interests in mind -- tell you what to do with it and how much you need to cover up in order to not be a tool of the patriarchy.

Halloween is a time to let loose and have fun. It's a time to dress in silly costumes and for quite a few of us it also involves sex and booze.

Where what you like and have fun.

[0+] Author Profile Page Tabitha said:

I've worn "sexy" cat costumes and the like and see no problem with it.

And sometimes, I just like dressing in a sexy way...

I don't think that looking pretty/sexy/attractive is unfeminist. Some lucky feminists are just lovely without even trying (although you'll never see that in the media).

It's when women are expected to sacrifice their personal preferences, their own sense of individuality, their safety (5inch heels, anyone?), or any aspect of who they are to fulfill the societal role of what a "woman" should be.

[0+] Author Profile Page Toni said:

I understand how you feel. It's not my Halloween costume this year (which is Luna Lovegood BTW) but a costume I'm working on for future anime conventions. Lucy from Elfen Lied. Lucy has several different outfits throughout the series but I decided to go with her covered in bandages like she is in many promotional pictures. While it's not like typical "sexy" costumes that look like lingre(can't spell) it's still revealing.

[0+] Author Profile Page Shy Mox replied to Toni :

I just wanna tell you that you're cool for deciding to go as Lucy ^_^ And now I'm curious what a feminist commentary on Elfen Lied would be >.>

[0+] Author Profile Page nikki#2 replied to Toni :

Ooh I would love to see a good bandage Lucy costume. Will you include the helmet (don't know what else to call it) too?

While I different ideas about sexual objectification than most of the feminists who have commented thus far, I will pass on something I was once told something by another feminist in passing while we were discussing a similar topic. Since having this conversation, I have been, somewhat, put at ease.

She said, "The difference between a feminist woman and just any other woman is that while she may desire to be a sexual object, she doesn't only desire to be a sexual object."

Keep in mind that this was said in passing and with a certain intention, not meaning non-feminist-identifying women want only to be seen as sexual objects, but that a feminist woman also lives in a world where these temptations exist.

[0+] Author Profile Page Okra said:

"So yeah, it's kind of just the luck of being a woman."

This sentence struck me as inexpressably poignant.

So much bad "luck" out there, no? So many accidents of birth resulting in female sexual organs, ethnic minorities, gay people, and other unluckies.

Funny how "luck" just happens...it's no one's fault...it's just the way things are, and have been...some people are just born "unluckier" than others...and we have to shrug and pull out the old lacy bra and take our unlucky lumps.

Maybe we should be working (harder) on trying to change our existential bad "luck."

Leave a comment


Search Feministing
About Feministing Community
Feministing Community is a forum for a variety of feminist voices and organizations.
Related Posts
Related Feministing Posts
Upcoming Events
  • Truth Revealed Campaign: Fighting against CPCs in Baltimore
    Tuesday, 13 October 2009 06:00 PM to 08:00 PM
    Planned Parenthood of Maryland
    Baltimore, MD
  • 6th Annual Benefit to End Domestic Violence Among Youth
    Tuesday, 13 October 2009 06:30 PM to 09:30 PM
    The Bowery Hotel
    New York, NY
  • "Sex Education in the City"
    Tuesday, 13 October 2009 06:30 PM to 08:30 PM
    National Council of Jewish Women
    New York, NY
  • Colorado Coalition Against Sexual Assault (CCASA) Fundraiser
    Wednesday, 14 October 2009 06:00 PM to 09:00 PM
    Scruffy Murphy's Irish Pub
    Denver, CO
  • Love Your Body All the Way Out of The Closet
    Thursday, 15 October 2009 07:00 PM to 10:00 PM
    Asefu's (Upstairs)
    Washington, DC

Recent Community Comments
Feministing As You Like It
Get involved with Feministing by joining our networks on:
Subscribe to Feministing