Social Media Pregnancies – Where to Draw the Line?

If you’re like me, chances are by the age of 28 that you’ve had a few female friends announce on Facebook that they’re pregnant by posting early sonograms, a progression of baby bump photos and enthusiastic updates for nine months. And let’s not forget about the eery 3-D sonograms showing a nearly full-term baby weeks away from being born.

It’s been almost a year since three fuzzy-looking sonograms from three different female friends appeared unsolicited on my Facebook NewsFeed within a week, generating a strong response from me that was somewhere between sincere congratulations and “This is too much to share on Facebook” and “I really don’t want to see her unborn fetus and into her uterus.” I hadn’t seen or spoken to two of these Facebook friends since college and the third woman I run into on occasion. So, if they were my closest friends posting pregnancy related updates, I know I would have a different reaction and be more accommodating and understanding.

But being a Women’s and Gender Studies graduate student, I couldn’t let it go and I turned the topic into an academic research paper months later. I still haven’t come across a lot of scholars, journalists or bloggers writing about how women are uniquely using Facebook and other social media technology (Twitter, Flickr, YouTube) to document and share their pregnancies and the implications this has for perceiving women’s bodies and fetal personhood. So, I was surprised to find this story buried in The Washington Post Style section on June 10.

The news article’s focus is mainly how more women feel comfortable documenting their pregnancies through social media as a way to share with extended family and friends and swap advice with other moms and moms-to-be. According to a 2010 study by software maker AVG, more than 30 percent of American mothers have posted their sonograms online. By the time they are age 2, 92 percent of American babies will have an online presence.

The Washington Post’s news article is an interesting trend piece but no one in the story talked about how using social media in this way reinforces fetal personhood in a very visible and public manner. Nor did anyone discuss how social media sites like Facebook can be seen as a technology through which we view women’s pregnant bodies, in a way that is similar to ultrasound technology, although different since it is social and not medical.

In our highly medicalized, American system of childbirth, we view women’s pregnant bodies and fetuses through ultrasounds, sonograms and fetal heart monitors without giving it a second thought. In the history of women’s childbearing, ultrasound technology and sonograms are a very recent medical and social development. A trained medical professional in a position of authority and power views the pregnant woman through ultrasound technology, interprets the ultrasound image and confers meaning on it regarding the fetus’ size, health and sex. The couple then shares the image with family and friends in a social ritual that allows them to reinforce the fetus’ individuality and personhood. The woman simply becomes a vessel for carrying and delivering a healthy fetus to term.

Add Facebook and other social media outlets, and the ritual is magnified. Not only are we viewing our pregnant Facebook friends’ bodies through their sonograms but also through their profiles, which are carefully maintained with certain information and photos. Lines of privacy are blurred since there isn’t a way to control who sees and who doesn’t see the sonogram. Endless opportunities exist for friends and family to comment on how the fetus or woman looks, to compare it with their own experiences or our cultural expectations of pregnancy, childbirth and motherhood. Not to mention the opportunities our online networks have to assign gender to the unborn child.

I don’t judge any woman who decides to document their pregnancy in this way. Ultimately, we individually choose how much or how little to share about ourselves online. Pregnancy is just a temporary state reflected in the constant flow of information on online social media. The presence and staying power of social media like Facebook and Twitter and its potential to add meaning to and change women’s daily, lived experiences is something that feminists need to be critical of and watchful.

Originally posted on http://feministconscience.wordpress.com/

and tagged , . Bookmark the permalink. Post a comment or leave a trackback: Trackback URL.

2 Comments

  1. Posted June 17, 2011 at 2:26 pm | Permalink

    Sorry not to be rude… but do you have any conclusions, recommendations, concerns, etc. that you would like to express?

    All this post really did was state in numerous ways how alot of women are sharing their pregnancies online in social media. It doesn’t really say whether you think that’s a good thing or not, or why we should care.

    Again I’m not trying to be rude – I actually found the basis for your article fascinating and I’d like to hear more which is why I was surprised you just seemed to kind of “stop” after you set the stage. Please elaborate.

  2. Posted June 17, 2011 at 11:06 pm | Permalink

    I actually have no problem with this phenomena. I was told in a history class in college that women don’t exist in history because they weren’t writing it down. Which was a fascinating thought to me. Because in history we try our best to sketch a picture of what an average woman experienced within her society at a given time. And I realized how much of my daily life nobody is ever going to know about. What are they going to know about a twenty-ish girl living in America in this century?

    And in a society where pregnancy is perceived more and more as a disease, I think it’s exciting that these women are excited to share their joy, hopes, and health with the people on their facebooks that care enough to flip through all the pictures. I know that when I left for college one of my best friends from high school got pregnant almost immediately and her posts on facebook were a way for me to keep up when I couldn’t be there with her. It was marvelous.

    I know there are a lot of debates about when “life” begins, but we do have to respect that many women believe life starts at conception and are excited about what that conception is going to bring. And they have just as much right to express that as those who don’t really care to see the sonograms. And it can open up great discussions on social sites about parenting styles and such. Granted, if a woman looses the baby or something goes wrong it may be hard to deal with everyone’s “concern” that would come through those same channels, but I’m sure, as grown women, they understand that risk. It’s comparable, I guess, to posting your relationship status.

    My main point, I guess, is that childbearing is a part of being a human who can carry another human being. And we shouldn’t feel like we need to keep that hidden or away from the public eye for fear of being “objectified” as a vessel or object in the same way that we don’t dress with collars up to our chins and hems down to the floor anymore. If you’re proud you can carry a child, be proud of that. It’s slightly rude for other people to begrudge someone for their ability to do that or for being proud of it. It’d be like begrudging someone for being successful at their jobs or having an outdoor picnic when you’re stuck inside all day. Being pregnant is something they’re doing, it’s what’s most important to them at this time, and they just want to let people into their happiness. Nothing there to resent.

Post a Comment

You must be logged in to post a comment.

171 queries. 0.474 seconds